![](https://img.dpic-cdn.org/images/Interior_of_unidentified_Court_House%E2%80%94Museum-of-History-New-South-Wales.jpg?w=150&h=150&q=60&auto=format&fit=crop&dm=1710428623&s=96e9a9e7f1ee298fcf21733532871b3b)
On Friday, March 8, 2024 a Johnston County trial court concluded a historic hearing regarding the claims of Hasson Bacote, a death-sentenced prisoner in North Carolina, that racial discrimination in jury selection played a role in his 2009 capital sentencing. The case, which is being reviewed pursuant to North Carolina’s 2009 Racial Justice Act (RJA), could have implications for more than 100 other death row prisoners who have pending claims under the Act.
The evidence presented by Mr. Bacote’s legal team during two weeks of testimony showed a clear and persistent pattern of racial bias in jury selection. They argued that racial bias has historically denied people of color the opportunity to serve on capital juries and led to a disproportionate number of extreme sentences for Black men, including Mr. Bacote.
In connection with the litigation, North Carolina disclosed 680,000 documents pertaining to data on capital punishment since 1980, including information on jury selection. The data show that potential Black jurors were four times more likely to be eliminated from a jury pool in Johnston County and ten times more likely to be eliminated by former District Attorney Gregory Butler, the prosecutor in Mr. Bacote’s case.
Henderson Hill, one of Mr. Bacote’s lawyers, argued that the racism in North Carolina’s death penalty was “so clear, it’s blinding.” “We have white prosecutors standing in front of overwhelmingly white juries comparing Black defendants facing the death penalty to animals – ‘mad dogs,’ ‘hyenas,’ ‘predators of the African plain,’” he said.
Mr. Butler denied the allegations that race played any role in Mr. Bacote’s case. “And, no, I was not calling them animals. There was no racial intent on my part whatsoever,” he said.
The RJA was passed by North Carolina in 2009, allowing persons sentenced to death to challenge their sentences based on the role race played in their sentencing and jury selection. Then, in 2013, the Act was fully repealed under Governor Pat McCrory.
The repeal was a response to the reaction of some North Carolina legislators, who complained that the RJA was an indirect way to abolish the death penalty in the state and caused delays in executions. The legislature’s initial attempt to repeal it in 2011 was vetoed by the then-Governor Bev Perdue. But cases that had already been filed under the RJA prior to the repeal, including that of Mr. Bacote, continue to proceed.
Serving on a jury is a fundamental constitutional right of United States citizens. Nonetheless, racial disparities in jury selections are not endemic to North Carolina. For many decades, and across the U.S., Black people were denied the right to serve on juries. The U.S. Supreme Court decision in Batson v. Kentucky (1986) confirmed that racial discrimination in jury selection is illegal, but the practice has continued.
Mr. Bacote is represented by the Center for Death Penalty Litigation, the ACLU’s Capital Punishment Project, the NAACP’s Legal Defense Fund, and North Carolina Attorney Jay Ferguson.
Superior Court Judge Wayland J. Sermons, Jr. is expected to issue his ruling in Mr. Bacote’s case later this Spring.
Sources
North Carolina Racial Justice Act, 2009 N.C. Sess. Laws 464 (codified as amended at N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 15A-2010 to 15A-2012); An Act to Amend the Racial Justice Act, 2012 N.C. Sess. Laws 136 (amending N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 15A-2010 to 15A-2012); An Act to Repeal the Racial Justice Act, 2013 N.C. Sess. Laws 154 (repealing N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 15A-2010 to 15A-2012).
Hill, C.S., Megan Byrne, Henderson, February 22, 2024. Challenging the Racist Death Penalty in North Carolina, ACLU. American Civil Liberties Union; Historic Hearing Challenging Racial Bias in North Carolina’s Death Penalty Concludes with Overwhelming Evidence of Discrimination in Capital Cases, March 8, 2024, American Civil Liberties Union; Historic Racial Justice Act hearing continues in Johnston County with first-of-its-kind evidence, March 4, 2024, CBS17.com; Lyons, K., March 8, 2024, Racial Justice Act hearing concludes — for now. NC Newsline; Lyons, K., 2024. Jury selection, stereotypes examined in Racial Justice Act hearing. NC Newsline; Racial Justice Act, n.d., The Center for Death Penalty Litigation; Hasson Bacote trial continues Tuesday, March 4, 2024, WRAL.com.
North Carolina
Jun 25, 2024
![Articles of Interest: A Look at the Difficulties Faced by Fathers on North Carolina’s Death Row](https://img.dpic-cdn.org/images/Fathers-on-Death-Row.png?w=300&h=300&q=60&auto=format&fit=crop&dm=1719339179&s=bb2f3c052c96504e32a72d4800b97e24)